This novel is set in the 1870’s which was difficult for me to get into at first because I have no romanticized ideas regarding the past. The lead female is a divorced woman with two children and she is shunned by everyone and is an outcast living with her unwed aunt. Rosalynn (the lead) gets a desperate letter from her estranged sister to come to Peaceful, Minnesotta. When they get to Minnesota they find a half Lakota gentleman named Lone Wolf living where her sister should be. The book is about falling in love after tremendous hurt and trusting again.
I finally got into the story but I think I would have died if I lived in this version of 1870 with how proper and hidden everyones feelings are. I kept screaming in my head, “Just tell him you love him. Reach out and touch him. Anything.”
The other thing that caught me off guard was the amount of religion in the book. The two main characters are constantly praying and they even go to church twice. Admittedly I don’t read very many LDS books so I guess I just wasn’t prepared for religion being such a big part of the story. It didn’t appeal to me.
The story gets interesting but in a very predictable way towards the end when some outside conflict threatens to tear the family apart. Roslynn deals with persecution because she is divorced and Lone Wolf deals with persecution because he is part Indian. They try to figure out if they can trust each other and love despite all the negativity from the world and their past experiences.
I had my mom read this book because I thought she might like it and she said it was a cross between Louis L’Amour and a Hallmark movie. What a perfect description. If that appeals to you I think you will enjoy this book.
Alisa
**********
I found the book a little boring for my taste, it’s just set up for everything to go too smoothly. The only real conflict is at the very end, and I thought it was entirely predictable. I felt like I was was skimming through most of the book waiting and waiting and waiting for something to happen. When it finally does, it was more a feeling of relief then a high point of tension. It wasn’t until the end that I realized the story is actually more about the emotional strife of the main character Rosalynn, and not supposed to be plot driven. The best parts of the book were Rosalynns inner struggles to let go of her own demons. I can’t relate to having an abusive husband, but I could relate to her feelings of mistrust, and the genuine angst she related. With that in mind the book was very real to me, albeit a little cheesy and forseeable.
Laura
**********
The premise of this book interested me enough, since I’m typically a fan of period novels that cross cultures and deal with issues like divorce, but I really struggled to get into this particular story. The dialogue felt contrived and borderline-corny from the start, including Rosalynn’s inner dialogue, and the characters were not developed enough for me to invest in them. The only flaw in Rosalynn was her past, which was her abusive husband’s fault anyway; otherwise she was perpetually perfect in her appearance, her mothering, her cleaning, her cooking, her everything. Lone Wolf, too, was constantly beautiful, constantly hard-working and efficient, constantly loyal and considerate, constantly saying and doing the right thing.
Rosalynn and Lone Wolf were so obviously in love with each other, yet half the book was spent on their questioning the other’s affections. And while this conflict felt way too drawn-out, the other conflicts of the book seemed too conveniently resolved to feel realistic.
Julianne
**********
It is my fault that we haven’t posted this sooner. I read it awhile back, and forgot about posting my not-so-glamorous review. I guess I felt bad that I read a book, didn’t really enjoy it, but finished it, knowing that I needed to write something about it. (If I didn’t have the obligation of writing about it, I might not have finished it.)
But if I’m going to find something nice to say, it would be that I did like the plot. I think it could be an enticing story. I always love a good love story. And, with the unlikely couple of a Lakota Native American and a while woman, I did like that Rosalynn was a forward-thinking, strong-willed, intelligent woman. However, the writing is cheesy and juvenile. Those are the only words I can think that really sum it up. (Possibly because this is Weikel’s first novel.) I think had I read this as a young teenager, I might have liked it. But having read some fantastic material in the last few years, I found myself quite bored.
Elaine
You can find Under a Lakota Moon by Deborah L. Weikel at: Amazon